Home Page
About the MTA
Join the MTA
Contribute
MTA News & Events
Contact the MTA
Links
Contact Your Representative
MTA Blog
Recall 1983 - Learn More
2008 State Representative Grades

The Michigan Taxpayers Alliance has compiled a list of key tax-related votes that were voted on by the House of Representatives in the past couple years. Each Representative was then graded based upon their voting record of these votes. The results can be viewed below:
Michigan Taxpayers Alliance 2008 State Representative Grades – Key Tax Votes

The following votes each count for three points.

1. 2007 House Bill 5194: The 12% state income tax hike.

2. 2007 House Bill 5198: The extension of the state sales tax to certain services, later replaced by a 22% business tax hike.

3. 2007 Senate Bill 94: Michigan’s new business tax. Citizens collected nearly 375,000 signatures on a petition to eliminate the despised old Single Business Tax. The petition language stated that the SBT should be replaced with a “less burdensome tax”. What did the legislature do? Replaced the tax with the Michigan Business Tax which increased the net tax burden on businesses, and is perhaps even more complicated than the old SBT.

4. Senate Bill 229, Senate Bills 232-235, House Bills 4344, 4346, 4348, 4350 and 4360: Increases in state spending from 2007 to 2008.

The remaining four votes count for two points each.

5. 2007 House Bill 4261. This bill authorized a new 2% tax on Kent County and Lansing hotels. The convention and tourism bureaus in Kent County and Lansing wanted more money, but apparently couldn’t get enough local hotels to send it to them voluntarily.

6. 2008 House Bill 5804: This bill funds the state’s Department of History, Arts and Libraries. Last year, the state spent $49.5 million on this Department. Governor Granholm recommended a spending increase to $52.7 million but that wasn’t enough for Speaker Dillon and the House leaders. They passed this bill increasing art spending to $57.1 million – a 13% increase. What’s in YOUR wallet?

7. 2008 Senate Bill 1107: This bill increased spending for school aid by almost half a billion dollars. The House added a provision allowing the Detroit Public Schools (DPS) to continue to be the only “district of the first class” in Michigan which prohibits Detroit’s district from facing additional competition from charter schools. The DPS was given this extra ‘protection’ for free. No audits, reforms or improvement plans were expected of the DPS in the legislation.

8. House Bills 4865, 4866, 5257 and 5258: Fee increases. Back in Governor Granholm’s first term, a whole slew of fee hikes were enacted on everything from gasoline to business licenses and annual reports required of non-profit corporations. The fee increases ranged from 25% to 100%. But don’t worry, citizens were told, these fee hikes are only “temporary” and will go away in 2007. The legislature put the “sunset date” for these temporary fee hikes right in the legislation.

Then on Sept 30, 2007, the day the fees increases were scheduled to go away, the legislature passed new legislation keeping the fee hikes in place. But don’t worry, these fees will go back down on September 30, 2012. It says so right in the legislation.

State Representative Grades

Each representative is listed in order of their house district number along with their corresponding grade. You can click on the representative's name to see a detailed description of how they voted on each vote and how their grade was tabulated. If you're not sure who your State Representative is, you can do a search on the House of Representative's website here or refer to the district map below.

Representative
House District Party Grade
Ed Gaffney House District 1 Republican F
LaMar Lemmons House District 2
Democrat F-
Bettie Cook Scott House District 3 Democrat F-
Coleman Young II House District 4 Democrat F-
Bert Johnson House District 5 Democrat F-
Marsha Cheeks House District 6 Democrat F-
Virgil Smith House District 7 Democrat F-
George Cushingberry House District 8 Democrat F-
Shanelle Jackson House District 9 Democrat F-
Gabe Leland House District 10 Democrat F-
Morris Hood House District 11 Democrat F-
Steve Tobocman House District 12 Democrat F-
Barbara Farrah House District 13 Democrat F-
Ed Clemente House District 14 Democrat F-
Gino Polidori House District 15 Democrat F-
Bob Constan House District 16 Democrat F-
Andy Dillon House District 17 Democrat F-
Richard LeBlanc House District 18 Democrat F-
John Pastor House District 19
Republican A+
Marc Corriveau House District 20
Democrat F
Philip LaJoy House District 21 Republican B
Hoon-Yung Hopgood House District 22 Democrat F-
Kathleen Law House District 23
Democrat F-
Jack Brandenburg House District 24
Republican B
Steve Bieda House District 25
Democrat F-
Marie Donigan House District 26 Democrat F-
Andy Meisner House District 27
Democrat F-
Lisa Wojno House District 28 Democrat F-
Tim Melton House District 29 Democrat F-
Torry Rocca House District 30 Republican E
Fred Miller House District 31
Democrat F-
Dan Acciavatti House District 32 Republican B
Kim Meltzer House District 33 Republican A
Brenda Clack House District 34
Democrat F-
Paul Condino House District 35
Democrat F-
Brian Palmer House District 36
Republican A+
Aldo Vagnozzi House District 37
Democrat F-
Craig DeRoche House District 38
Republican A
David Law House District 39
Republican B
Chuck Moss House District 40 Republican A
Marty Knollenberg House District 41 Republican A
Frank Accavitti House District 42
Democrat F-
Fran Amos House District 43
Republican A
John Stakoe House District 44 Republican C
John Garfield House District 45 Republican A
Jim Marleau House District 46 Republican B
Joe Hune House District 47 Republican A-
Richard Hammel House District 48 Democrat F-
Lee Gonzales House District 49 Democrat F-
Ted Hammon House District 50 Democrat F-
David Robertson House District 51 Republican B
Pam Byrnes House District 52 Democrat F-
Rebekah Warren House District 53 Democrat F-
Alma Smith House District 54 Democrat F-
Kathy Angerer House District 55 Democrat F-
Kate Elbi House District 56 Democrat F-
Dudley Spade House District 57 Democrat F-
Bruce Caswell House District 58
Republican D
Rick Schaffer House District 59
Republican D
Robert Jones House District 60 Democrat F-
Jack Hoogendyk House District 61 Republican A+
Mike Nofs House District 62 Republican D
Lawrence Wenke House District 63 Republican C
Martin Griffin House District 64 Democrat F
Mike Simpson House District 65 Democrat F
Chris Ward House District 66 Republican E
Barb Byrum House District 67 Democrat F-
Joan Bauer House District 68 Democrat F-
Mark Meadows House District 69 Democrat F-
Judy Emmons House District 70 Republican D
Rick Jones House District 71 Republican C+
Glen Steil House District 72 Republican B-
Tom Pearce House District 73 Republican C
David Agema House District 74 Republican N/A
Robert Dean House District 75 Democrat F-
Michael Sak House District 76 Democrat F-
Kevin Green House District 77 Republican D
Neal Nitz House District 78 Republican C
John Proos House District 79 Republican D
Tonya Schuitmaker House District 80 Republican C+
Phil Pavolv House District 81 Republican B+
John Stahl House District 82 Republican A
John Espinoza House District 83 Democrat F-
Terry Brown House District 84 Democrat F-
Dick Ball House District 85 Republican E
Dave Hildenbrand House District 86 Republican C+
Brian Calley House District 87 Republican E
Fulton Sheen House District 88 Republican A+
Arlan Meekhof House District 89 Republican C
Bill Huizenga House District 90 Republican D-
Mary Valentine House District 91 Democrat F-
Doug Bennett House District 92 Democrat F-
Paul Opsommer House District 93 Republican D
Kenneth Horn House District 94 Republican C
Andy Coulouris House District 95 Democrat F-
Jeff Mayes House District 96 Democrat F-
Tim Moore House District 97 Republican D-
John Moolenaar House District 98 Republican D
Bill Caul House District 99 Republican D-
Geoff Hansen House District 100 Republican E
David Palsrock House District 101
Republican D
Darwin Booher House District 102
Republican D
Joel Sheltrown House District 103
Democrat F-
Howard Walker House District 104 Republican B
Kevin Elsenheimer House District 105 Republican B+
Matt Gillard House District 106
Democrat F-
Gary McDowell House District 107 Democrat F-
Tom Casperson House District 108
Republican C
Steven Lindberg House District 109
Democrat F-
Michael Lahti House District 110
Democrat F-